• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sorrento's Restaurant: Authentic Italian Cuisine in Syracuse, NY | Fresh, Made-from-Scratch Meals

Sorrento's Restaurant, nestled in Syracuse, NY, is a charming Italian gem where every dish is crafted from scratch with fresh, authentic ingredients. Known for its homemade sauces, dressings, and desserts, this BYOB spot offers rich, flavorful meals like Chicken Francaise and Portuguese long hots that leave a lasting impression. Though the interior is modest and service can be unhurried, the genuine, old-school atmosphere complements the heartfelt cooking. The attentive staff and consistently excellent flavors make Sorrento’s a standout for true Italian food lovers seeking quality and tradition without pretense. A must-visit for an honest, satisfying Italian dining experience.

Sorrento's Restaurant at a glance

  • Address 3770 Brewerton Rd, Syracuse, NY 13212, United States
  • Phone +1 315-378-4386
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant .

Sorrento's Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

David Bellso
5

If you want every dish made from scratch and don't mind waiting a little extra for it this is a place for you. The food is as good as it gets and seeing its a BYOB you save money too. Yes it's ugly inside and out, yes service is slow but that is what you get when you want fresh made to order food. Dressing is homemade as well and all deserts are made right there. Don't judge this book by its cover, you will be truly surprised and happy! Give your taste buds a treat, take them to Sorrento's.

Kathy Kitt
5

Beans & greens to go back for any time! This is a true Italian restaurant with consistently great food. Their sauce is the best I've tasted in Syracuse. The wait-staff is experienced, friendly, and always eager to please. Love this place!

AJ
5

I've eaten here a couple of times with my family, and both times I left very satisfied. I most recently ordered the Chicken Francaise and it came out fresh and delicious, one of the best I've had in fact. The Portuguese long hots and greens appetizers were both phenomenal as well. The Syracuse area is littered with quality Italian eateries, and this place is a prime example of an inconspicuous Italian eatery that deserves more recognition!

JCvintage
5

My boyfriend and I drove past this place several times and decided we’d give it a try for dinner, I can’t begin to mention how outstanding the service was and how tasteful the food was. The atmosphere was old school Italian and welcoming, I wish we tried out this place sooner! Thank you for a delightful first experience, we definitely will be returning

Brendan Perperian
4

The food was delicious. The staff here are friendly and the atmosphere isn’t as hectic as most other restaurants. The reason that I gave a 4 star rating is because I thought there could have been a little bit less sauce and less breading on the Piccata. Other than that it was very flavorful. I would highly recommend going here if anyone asked me about local restaurants. You’ll get a full Italian meal but remember to bring your own wine.

Eric Hess
5

Small, hole-in-the-wall restaurant. Excellent food and tremendous portions. I saw someone say that their prices are too high. McDonald's is right next door if you want anything cheaper because they have some of the cheapest prices I've noticed. It's an all-hands-on-deck scenario so sometimes the service isn't as swift as a lot of picky people would hope for. However, once the food comes out, you'll forget about all of that because the portions are right and the food tastes even better. I can imagine a lot of Negative Nancy's are looking for the servers to just hang around your table. No. Bring a bottle of wine, sit back, and enjoy yourselves. And by the way, it's not dirty there. I don't understand where anyone came up with that. Must be rival restaurants trying to bad-talk an excellent establishment. A MUST if you're in search of a new go-to.

Jamie Elliott
5

We eat there often and have never had a bad meal. We have tried almost everything on the menu. My spouse is vegetarian and there are plenty of delicious options for her. Best Chicken Marsala I have had. Great homemade sauces. Unbelievable tiramisu. Large portions and reasonable prices. Great lunch menu as well. Great location, near the airport and route 81. Wait staff outstanding.

Emily Jones
5

Wonderful hole in the wall restaurant with great, friendly staff! Patty and Debbie are always there to welcome with a warm smile and hug! Food has always been top notch. Be sure to bring your own wine or beer because they do not sell alcohol. Saves you a few bucks on drinks and you get a perfectly spledid dining experience! My husband and I are regulars!

Location

  • Sorrento's Restaurant
    Sorrento's Restaurant
    3770 Brewerton Rd, Syracuse, NY 13212, United States Hotline: +1 315-378-4386

Located in Syracuse, NY, Sorrento's Restaurant stands out as a genuine Italian dining gem that embraces tradition with every dish. This unassuming spot at 3770 Brewerton Rd invites diners who appreciate authentic, scratch-made Italian cuisine. The moment you step inside, you notice an old-school charm—modest décor paired with warm, welcoming service that makes every visit feel like a family gathering.

What truly defines Sorrento's is its commitment to freshness and quality. Each plate is prepared from scratch, ensuring that sauces are deeply flavorful and all dressings and desserts are homemade, a detail that elevates every bite. The slow pace of service reflects the care taken in creating every dish, rewarding patience with exceptional meals. A standout is the Chicken Francaise, praised for its fresh, tender preparation, alongside appetizers like Portuguese long hots and beans & greens, which capture genuine Italian-American comfort food at its finest.

Another unique advantage at Sorrento's is the BYOB policy, offering guests the chance to bring their favorite wine, perfectly complementing the hearty, rich flavors without the extra cost. The staff’s friendliness and attentiveness enhance the relaxed atmosphere, setting it apart from more rushed, hectic eateries.

Though the exterior and interior may seem modest—some might even call it 'ugly'—it's a classic case of not judging a book by its cover. Sorrento's is a deeply rewarding culinary experience for those who value authenticity and handmade quality over flashiness. For lovers of true Italian fare in Syracuse, this restaurant delivers a sincere, flavorful taste of Italy that’s hard to forget.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Dine-in